Better than in a Restaurant: Top 5 Breakfast Sandwich Makers to Fulfill Your Tastebuds

Wanna breakfast sandwich maker but don’t know how to choose it? We researched which criteria are important and which breakfast makers work best for each of them.
Check Out 5 Best Breakfast Sandwich Makers

Morning is the time when you want to sleep longer. At the very least, you are in a hurry to get ready for work or other business and to eat something quick, tasty, and preferably healthy seems unrealistic. Well, unless you can afford such a luxury on the weekend when you are not in a rush. This is the reality of many people, but I’m sure they just haven’t tried the breakfast sandwich maker yet. 

Many people say that this thing doesn’t make life easier, but harder. We don’t agree with them. It’s like with books: you just have to find the one that works for you. A little practice, a little experimentation, and you’ll already forget how you lived without a sandwich maker. And to choose properly, we’ve done the research and identified the finest models in different categories. 

Comparison table: 5 best breakfast sandwich makers

ModelCharacteristics
Editor's pick

Gotham Steel 2980 Breakfast Maker

Gotham Steel 2980 Breakfast Maker


Show price

Voltage: 120V
Weight: 2.78 kg
Dimensions: 12x12x6 inches
Material: Copper (ceramic nonstick coating)
Wattage: 750W

- The best for closed hot sandwiches
- 25% easier to clean than others from the list
- Ultra Nonstick.
- 100% PFOA Free
- Copper is birds-safe material

Go to a detailed review
Best Egg Sandwich Maker

Hamilton Beach 25490

Hamilton Beach 25490


Show price

Voltage: 100-120V
Weight: 4.8 kg
Dimensions: 7.83x10.39x5.91 inches
Material: Plastic (nonstick grids)
Wattage: 1200W

- Makes the best Egg McMuffins
- The best choice for couples as it can make two sandwiches at once
- Has a timer function
- Removable rings are easy to clean

Go to a detailed review
To Make The Tastiest Sandwiches

Hamilton Beach 25462Z Breakfast Maker

Hamilton Beach 25462Z Breakfast Maker


Show price

Voltage: 120V
Weight: 2.64 kg
Dimensions: 4.5x12.3x12.6 inches
Material: Plastic (nonstick grids)
Wattage: 1400W

- Makes the most delicious sandwiches according to our research
- Size makes it easy to store
- Heats up well and quickly & keeps warm
- Has an indicator (shows that the food is ready)

Go to a detailed review
Quickest & Easiest Use

Sandwich Maker by Drew&Cole

Sandwich Maker by Drew&Cole


Show price

Voltage: 220-240V
Weight: 1.6 kg
Dimensions: 14.5 cmx16cmx18cm
Material: Non-stick coating cooking board
Wattage: 600W

- The fastest in cooking sandwiches (less than 5 min)
- 2 times simpler to cook egg mcmuffins than others from the list
- Small size makes it easy to store
- Removable parts are easy to clean

Go to a detailed review
Easiest to Clean

Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Breakfast Sandwich Maker

Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Breakfast Sandwich Maker


Show price

Voltage: 110V
Weight: 5.72 kg
Dimensions: 13.5x11.5x7.12 inches
Material: Stainless Steel

- The easiest to clean (removable plates)
- Has many precise temperature options
- Has a grease trap and it works great
- Has a timer function
- 5 different cooking modes

Go to a detailed review

How did we choose?

Figuring out the many different sandwich makers is no easy task. They all seem to be similar and at the same time all different, right? That’s what we thought at first. But then we used our favorite method of research and it turns out that there aren’t many great sandwich makers, but they do exist. So what did we do?

  1. We started with market research and chose more than 20 of the most popular models with lots of reviews and a rating of at least 4.2 stars.
  2. Next, we selected the top 10 models for an in-depth study.
  3. We analyzed more than 500 reviews, which helped us identify 25 criteria for choosing a breakfast sandwich maker.
  4. Finally, we made our top 5 sandwich makers with the highest ratings and divided them into categories.

This methodology helps our team do two jobs simultaneously. We identify the most important criteria for product quality and determine a winner for each of them. 

Valuehunta® analysis methodology

Every Breakfast Sandwich Maker in Detail

Even though we’ve chosen five sandwich makers for our selection, they are different and all excellent in their way. Now we will tell you more about each of them so that you can figure out which one is best suited for your needs.

Gotham Steel 2980 Breakfast Maker — Editor’s pick

Check out the price and reviews on Amazon

Pros

  • The best for closed hot sandwiches
  • Has an indicator (shows that the food is ready)
  • Almost as easy to clean as Cuisinart GR-4NP1
  • 100% PFOA Free
  • Decent non-stick plates

Cons

  • Doesn’t have a power button
  • Some people say the material quality isn’t very high
  • If there is too much stuffing, it can leak out

If you’re looking for an affordable sandwich maker that makes a delicious breakfast sandwich for you quickly and easily, you should check out Gotham Steel 2980 Breakfast Maker. This is one of the few (the only one in our selection) sandwich makers that connects the edges of the sandwich so that it is maximally handy to eat. It’s a little harder to clean than the Cuisinart GR-4NP1 (review), but a wet paper towel does the job well.

And it has even one more twist to surprise you. If you have birds, you know that Teflon, PTFE, and PFOA are deadly to them because of the fumes they emit (these products are dangerous to us too, of course!). That’s why this sandwich maker with copper is much better in case you have home birds. 

Despite its many advantages, it is still not perfect. Because of the low price of the device, the material is quite cheap. Nevertheless, it is worth a try — it is like a few cups of coffee from Starbucks and a cupcake for the price.

Hamilton Beach 25490 — Best Egg Sandwich Maker

Check out the price and reviews on Hamilton Beach

Pros

  • Makes the best egg sandwiches such as Egg McMuffins from McDonald’s
  • Can make two sandwiches at once so it’s perfect for couples
  • Has a timer function
  • Removable rings are easy to clean

Cons

  • Some owners claim that it does not retain heat very well
  • The non-stick coating may come off slightly over time

The perfect sandwich maker to make egg mcmuffins for two for breakfast? Yes, it exists. And we’re about Hamilton Beach 25490 now. Besides, you don’t have to cook just eggs — it’s excellent for other dishes as well. A deli roast beef and some spicy provolone and you have an awesome lunch/dinner sandwich! Mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil, there are no limits here! Since it has removable parts, cleaning the sandwich maker won’t be a problem for you. Other nice bonuses are the timer and quick-cooking (almost as easy and quick as with Sandwich Maker by Drew&Cole (review)).

This may be the specifics of a particular unit, but we must warn you: some users have encountered the problem of insufficient heating of the sandwich maker. And some others have encountered poor customer service when they wanted to exchange or return merchandise, although these are rare cases.

Hamilton Beach 25462Z Breakfast Maker — To Make The Tastiest Sandwiches

Check out the price and reviews on Hamilton Beach

Pros

  • Cooks the most delicious sandwiches according to our research
  • Has a hinged floating lid for sandwiches of different thicknesses
  • Heats up well and quickly & keeps warm
  • Has an indicator (shows that the food is ready)
  • The size makes it easy to store

Cons

  • Doesn’t have a power button and temperature settings
  • It may be hard to clean because the cooking grills are not removable (but a paper towel or a damp sponge works well)

A sandwich maker that will perfectly grill any size sandwich for you and leave beautiful grill strips sounds like a real deal for you? Take a look at Hamilton Beach 25462Z Breakfast Maker then. A floating lid is something you don’t often see in an affordable sandwich maker, but this model is a pleasing exception. You can put as many toppings as you want in your sandwich and get the same great result (in comparison, Gotham Steel 2980 Breakfast Maker (review) deals great only with small sandwiches). By the way, burgers and steaks also turn out great in this machine. 

What sets this sandwich maker apart from more expensive models? It doesn’t have temperature settings or a power button, and the grills are not removable (the Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Breakfast Sandwich Maker (review) has these features). But if that doesn’t bother you, a paper towel or damp sponge will do the cleansing job decently.

‎Sandwich Maker by Drew&Cole — Quickest & Easiest Use

Check out the price and reviews on High Street TV

Pros

  • The fastest in cooking sandwiches (less than 5 min)
  • Almost as cool egg mcmuffins as with Hamilton Beach 25490
  • The small size makes it easy to store
  • Removable parts are easy to clean

Cons

  • You need to be careful with this one because the grill body can get overheated
  • There is not much space for stuffing (or it can leak out if you add too much)

Too lazy to mess around in the kitchen but want a quick, simple breakfast? Oh yes, Sandwich Maker by Drew&Cole will help you with that. It’s especially suitable if you live alone because, unlike the  Hamilton Beach 25490 (review), it can only cook one sandwich at a time. What else? All you have to do is throw in the ingredients, wait a few minutes, and your egg muffin is ready. Or any other dish — your imagination is limitless. See below for some breakfast ideas. Plus, it’s almost as easy to clean as the Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Breakfast Sandwich Maker (review) because the rings can be removed (and they’re dishwasher-safe).

It does have a few minor drawbacks that we have to tell you about. Parts of the grill can overheat, and you have to be careful when putting ingredients and taking out cooked food. Although it is convenient to store, its small size has its disadvantages. There isn’t much room for toppings in the sandwich maker, so you’re a little limited in that regard.

Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Breakfast Sandwich Maker — Easiest to Clean

Check out the price and reviews on Amazon

Pros

  • Easiest to clean (removable plates)
  • Has many precise temperature options
  • Has a grease trap and it works well
  • Has a timer function
  • 5 different cooking modes
  • There is an option of using either the griddle or the grill plates

Cons

  • Some users say it doesn’t heat up well & not keep warm long
  • The metal body of the grill gets hot and dangerous to touch (the handle is fine)
  • It’s a pricey one

If you’re willing to pay a little more for comfort and extra features, you can’t get past Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Breakfast Sandwich Maker. It’s not just the price that sets it apart from all the other sandwich makers on our list but also features like temperature settings, fully removable grill plates, a special grease trap, and 5 cooking modes. You have so many options to cook with it: burgers, paninis, toast, burritos, hot dogs, fried eggs, pancakes, sausages, chicken breasts, grilled cheese and this is a non-exhaustive list. Although it doesn’t have a floating lid to experiment with the thickness of your sandwiches like Hamilton Beach 25462Z Breakfast Maker (review).

Despite the many cool twists, even this grill is not perfect. Some users have complained that this sandwich maker doesn’t heat up well and takes a long time to cook any food. Although these are quite rare cases, they did happen. And yes, it’s ironic, but other owners have said that the grill, on the contrary, overheats and it’s dangerous to touch anything but the handle. So I guess it depends on the occasion and individual perception. 

Breakfast Sandwich Maker vs Bread Toaster vs Panini Maker: What’s the difference?

You can make a delicious breakfast with any of these appliances, but how do you know the difference and which is better? The sandwich maker and the panini maker are sometimes interchangeable, but let’s sort it out in order.

✅ A classic sandwich maker is a device for preparing closed hot sandwiches.

✅ The toaster is a device designed to fry slices of bread.

✅ A panini press is a small, weighty grill. It fries the sandwich slices and leaves those great grill lines you see on the surface. 

Comparison table

Criteria Toaster Sandwich Maker Panini Press
Device DesignThe toaster works like an electric stove witd heated spirals. It can cook from 2 to 4 toast at a time.A sandwich maker is two heated plates, between which a closed sandwich is placed.Similar to a small grill, usually has a floating lid for different thicknesses of sandwiches.
FunctionsThe main task of a toaster is to make toast and that’s it.Makes hot sandwiches witd stuffing, but can have many additional functions similar to a panini press.You can use the device not only for grilling paninis but also for quickly frying meat, vegetables, fish, and even fruit.
PriceIt’s usually the lowest cost.More expensive than a toaster, but cheaper than a panini, if you take the average cost.Usually costs a little more than a sandwich maker, but it depends on the function.
Toast ThicknessOnly bread of a certain thickness should be placed in the toasterIn a sandwich maker, you can usually experiment with the bread thickness, but you can’t put much stuffing inside.You can take any size of bread, but more exciting, you can put as much stuffing as you want as long as the lid is floating.

Which is better? It depends on your needs. If you only want hot toast, a toaster will suffice. If you want simple closed hot sandwiches, or McDonald’s egg muffins, look no further than a sandwich maker. If you like paninis and open sandwiches in general with nice grill strips, as well as the ability to cook additional vegetables, meat, and other dishes, a panini press would be the best choice.  By the way, you can also make regular toast in a sandwich maker and panini press, no toppings necessary.

It is important to understand that these three household appliances — sandwich maker, panini press, and toaster — can partially complement and replace each other, but their functions cannot be considered completely identical. 

15 dishes you can cook with a breakfast maker

How obvious would it be to start with classic sandwiches? Okay, let’s not bore you with that.

Here are our top dishes that you can try to cook with your breakfast sandwich maker (ideal for Gotham Steel 2980 Breakfast Maker (review)):

  1. Apple pies are like McDonald’s. 
  2. Pizza will be your obvious favorite.
  3. Great for eggs and small omelets too. Like an omelet bar. 
  4. Waffles, if there is a removable plate for them.
  5. Anything you can get in the form of hot pockets (unless you choose the form of a panini press).

Additional ideas if you choose a panini press like Hamilton Beach 25462Z Breakfast Maker (review) or Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Breakfast Sandwich Maker (review):

  1. Bacon
  2. Pork chops
  3. A Philly steak sandwich
  4. Burritos
  5. Hot dogs
  6. Pancakes
  7. Fried onions
  8. Sausages
  9. Chicken breasts
  10. Fried cheese.

As you can see, there are so many options, except that sandwiches can also come in all kinds of fillings! Such a device as a sandwich maker is sure to diversify your food life, you just have to choose which device is best for you.

Summary

The sandwich maker can become your indispensable assistant in the kitchen if you choose it correctly. It can reduce the time for cooking breakfast and diversify your ration, and it can be a healthy meal as well. 

When choosing this device, we advise you to pay attention to the material, ease of cleaning, speed and ease of cooking, and additional functions, if you like timers or temperature modes. Our research is based on feedback from real users, but we still advise you to read reviews of the chosen model on the website to be sure of your choice. Remember that there are no perfect things (just like people), and there will always be someone who will not like a particular sandwich maker. All you have to do is decide which points are critical to you and which are not, and the choice will become obvious.

FAQ

🥪How does the breakfast sandwich maker work?

A sandwich maker is two heated plates, between which a closed sandwich is placed. All you have to do is throw in the topping sandwich pieces and close the lid of the appliance. Usually, they don’t even have buttons for anything.

🍳Can I make an egg on a sandwich maker?

Yes, you can. The best option for eggs is Hamilton Beach 25490 which has a separate egg compartment

🤨What is a breakfast sandwich maker?

A classic sandwich maker is a device for preparing closed hot sandwiches.

🔍Which is a good brand for the sandwich maker?

We advise you to pay attention to Gotham Steel 2980 Breakfast Maker for classic closed sandwiches, Hamilton Beach 25490 for egg mcmuffins, and Hamilton Beach 25462Z Breakfast Maker for open sandwiches like paninis.

Total
0
Shares
Related Posts
Read More

Experts’ Choice: Top 5 Bullet Blenders in 2022

Are you an athlete who follows a proper diet? A business person who doesn't have time to cook? Or just someone keen on cooking smoothies, shakes, and various drinks with a blender? It doesn't matter what your goals are. In any case, thanks to our article, you will be able to choose the best model from our top 5 bullet blenders.
?1Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!