Proved By Experts And Users Best Toaster Oven Under $100

Roomy & compact toaster ovens for perfect roasts. Experts short-list of budget reliable well-built models.

Mass production technologies make it possible to produce the necessary consumer goods quickly and their cost is minimal. Therefore, today you have a huge selection of budget toaster ovens for up to $100.

For the price of 20 Big Macs, you will definitely find a reliable and roomy toaster oven. With this device, you will bake cookies, cook pizza, roast chicken, and, finally, make perfect toasts for the whole family.

In this review, we have tested models that will work for years in your kitchen.

Best reliable toaster ovens under $100

Black + Decker TO3250XSB
Winner in categories:
Roominess & quick roasting
Exterior Dimensions: 14.5” x 22” x 11.5”;
Interior Dimensions: 16.5” x 12.5” x 9.5”;
Adjustable Temperature: 200-450 °F;
Adjustable Timer: The 60-minute precision timer features stay-on functionality;
Cord length: 24 Inches;
Type: knob.
Toshiba AC25CEW-BS
Winner in categories:
Easy to use & the fastest preheating time
Exterior Dimensions: 18.98” x 15.59” x 10.78”;
Interior Dimensions: 12.13” × 9.84” × 6.30”;
Adjustable Temperature: 150-400 °F;
Adjustable Timer: Up to 2 hours;
Cord length: 40 Inches;
Type: knob.
Hamilton Beach 31123D
Winner in category:
Perfect roasting
Exterior Dimensions: 15” x 18.5” x 9.5”;
Interior Dimensions: 13” x 7.5” x 12”;
Adjustable Temperature:150-842 ° F;
Adjustable Timer: up to 30 minutes;
Cord length: 36 inches;
Type: knob.
Mueller MT-175
Winner in category:
Fastest heating
Exterior Dimensions: 18" x 10" x 11";
Interior Dimensions: 13" x 9.25" x 7.75";
Adjustable Temperature: 150-450 °F;
Adjustable Timer: Up to 30 min with Stay-On Setting;
Cord length: 36 inches;
Type: knob.
Hamilton Beach 31344
Winner in category:
Smallest and lightest toaster oven
Exterior Dimensions: 8.97" x 16.12" x 11.93";
Interior Dimensions: approx. 6” x 11" x 9.125";
Adjustable Temperature: 200-450°F;
Adjustable Timer: 30-minute timer with auto shutoff;
Cord length: 30 inches;
Type: knob.
Elite Gourmet ERO-2008S
Winner in category:
Easy-care system
Exterior Dimensions: 17" x 13.5" x 14.5";
Interior Dimensions: 12" x 8.5" x 13";
Adjustable Temperature: 200-450°F;
Adjustable Timer: 60-Minute Timer with Stay-On Setting;
Cord length: 36 inches;
Type: knob.
Black + Decker CT06335S
Winner in category:
Convection toaster oven
Exterior Dimensions: 10.5" x 19.25" x 13.375";
Interior Dimensions: 13.5" x 10 " x 5.5";
Adjustable Temperature: 200-450˚F;
Adjustable Timer: silent mode, up to 120 minutes;
Cord length: 23,5 inches;
Type: button.
Winner in category:
Safest toaster oven
Exterior Dimensions: 19.72" x 16.29" x 11.33"
Interior Dimensions: 14" x 8.5" x 12";
Adjustable Temperature: 150-450 ˚F;
Adjustable Timer: 90-minute timer;
Cord length: 31.5 inch;
Type: button.

What budget toaster oven is the best

Surely, you have already tried to choose a toaster oven yourself and found several thousand models that are very similar to each other (and this is only up to $100). Indeed, there are a wide variety of models on the market today. And in a situation with budget toaster ovens, our task is to help you choose a high-quality and most suitable model for your needs.

To select quality products for you, we consulted with customers, employees of service centers, and with several manufacturers. We also tested the selected toaster ovens. This article is not sponsored by any company. Therefore, only reliable and proven products are placed in our recommendations.

Even if you spend 4-5 days reading reviews on Amazon and YouTube, we do not guarantee that this will help you make the best choice. Some manufacturers place only attractive information in promotional materials.

Also, you should be critical of the opinions of people you have never met in your life. Can you trust Mr. Jack from Arkansas who wrote that his oven does not make toast well? You should wonder how that particular user followed the directives in the instruction manual. 

Even if you collect and analyze a sufficient (more than 900) number of reviews, spent about a week on this, you can find that the reviews were written … by robots not real people. 

In general, take the simpler and more reliable path. Consider the opinion of those companies whose selection is based on the analysis of big (and real) data.

Significant criteria when choosing a toaster oven

We polled over 730 real users about their experience with toaster ovens. Based on this data and the recommendations of technical experts, we have selected really important criteria that should be guided by when buying a toaster oven.

So, a perfect toaster oven:

  • Perfect roasts, warms up quickly
  • Roomy & compact
  • Matches with the interior, has an elegant design
  • Has a thoughtful functional design
  • Easy to use
  • Has well-built construction and it is easy to clean

For example, when choosing functionality, pay attention to ease of use and clarity of modes. And such an option as “quiet operation” was not even included in the top 8 important criteria. Because real users understand that if it is a convection toaster oven, then a fan will work inside it, which will make a low sound.

Top budget toaster ovens (under $100)

Black + Decker TO3250XSB

Buy two Black + Decker TO3250XSB toaster ovens for $150 both and throw away your full size oven, you won’t need it anymore.

For about 350 days a year, you will cook everything in this toaster oven. If you want to prepare a lot of dishes for the holiday… just remove the same toaster oven from the cabinet.

Among the budget toaster ovens, this model is one of the most spacious. Moreover, it simultaneously has two important characteristics — in addition to the large space inside (specially engineered), it is at the same time very compact and does not take up much space in your kitchen.

It heats up quickly and evenly. This is a convection toaster oven , so your food will cook faster and roast more evenly.

For improved cooking flexibility you can use the original toaster pan and place it in 3 different positions.

📌 Things to consider:

You will receive only 1 rack with the oven. This is not done because of the cheapness, but because if you put 2 racks, the upper part of the lower shelf and the lower part of the upper shelf will not heat up evenly enough.

Yes, it may be toasting for half a minute longer than your old toaster oven, but keep in mind that during this time you are making 8 toasts for the whole family at once. That it is much, much faster overall.

Toshiba AC25CEW-BS

Among the best budget toaster ovens, this model is well-built, which makes it look like a more expensive device. Users also noted this when using the toaster oven — the door does not let heat through and fits snugly, the oven heats up quickly, you can use the convection function for more powerful frying, the control panel is simple enough and intuitive for the user.

📌 Things to consider:

If you don’t read the manual and toast “just like in an old toaster oven”, then toast most likely will be burnt. This oven will roast them faster.

Since this toaster oven is more powerful than other budget models (and it is also more powerful than the old ones), it may take some time to remember what temperature and time to set for the best cooking of your dishes.

Hamilton Beach 31123D

One of the important advantages of this model is the functionality of its design. The door on this toaster oven rises very high, so its use is safe (no burns) and more convenient (no need to hold the door with your hand).

Also, this model has very high working temperatures (2 times higher than other models from our review). Thanks to this, dishes will be cooked in it almost instantly.

Some companies sell products that are more profitable for them. Since our work is not sponsored by any manufacturer, you can familiarize yourself with the most complete and detailed comparison of the best Hamilton Beach models.

Spoiler alert: A large digit in the model number does not mean that this oven is better than others.

So, the 31123D model is the best choice — it can work at high temperatures (some users even used it for clay firing). It also has a convection function, which reduces cooking time by about 30%.

For the best user experience, we recommend you to use a 12 x 10 Inch Pan Tray, which is ideal for the 31123B model.

📌 Things to consider:

Since this model can be heated to very high temperatures, its surface can be hot outside too.

Mueller MT-175

This model is well designed, there is no extra heat loss or gaps on the door. Therefore, she is very quick to toast or bake cakes. In addition, it is very easy and quick to clean, grease and crumbs do not get into hard-to-reach corners or heating elements. This increases the likelihood that it will serve you for several years without any breakdowns. The company is confident in the quality of its products, so this model is covered by a long warranty (up to 2 years). Of course, with the toaster oven, you also get 2 the most important documents — A Temperature Guide for different kinds of foods and a nice little recipe book.

Advice: be sure to read the instruction manual of the selected model. Each toaster oven has its own unique setting. So, for example, the same “toast” mode has completely different temperatures and cooking times (it all depends on the power of your model).

📌 Things to consider:

The temperature setting here will be less accurate than in the digitally controlled models. We recommend that you study the manual for this particular model in order to correctly set the timer for toasting toast or cooking other dishes.

Hamilton Beach 31344D

It is a “we love the door” model. Almost all buyers said that this model fits perfectly into the interior, does not take up much kitchen space, and has a well thought out and functional design. 

The door opens completely upwards, making it very convenient to get hot food out of it. You can also remove this cover and clean it separately, wipe well all surfaces inside, which greatly simplifies the cleaning process.

There are also other 2 very similar Hamilton Beach models on the market.

Comparison of models Hamilton Beach 31344 & 31334 & 31337

They differ from this model in size and appearance (be sure to look at the stylish red model 31337), the main functionality is identical.
This model (31344) is the newest among them, so we recommend purchasing it.

📌 Things to consider:

This is a very compact toaster oven, so it is less spacious than our top-pick Black + Decker TO3250XSB. Its maximum capacity is for 4-slices of toast or 9 inch pizza. This model is hardly suitable for a large family with children, but rather a best choice for one person or a couple.

Elite Gourmet ERO-2008S model

(other brand names: Elite Cuisine or Maxi-Matic)

Elite Gourmet produces 2 very similar models. The price difference between the two is around $15.

Model 2008N has 5 main modes for rotisserie, broil, bake, toast, & keep warm.

Model 2008S has +3 additional modes (8 in total) — oven-top grill, griddle and steamer with dome lid.

So we recommend you to buy model 2008S with wider mode range.

The uniqueness of the design (as you already understand from the photo) lies in the fact that this toaster oven has a special rotisserie cooking option.

The manufacturer is attentive to the market situation and knows the current needs of consumers.

About 80% of customers use it as an alternative to a regular oven. That is why the 2008S/N models let you not only bake cookies, but also allows you to make rotisserie chicken. 

Advise: choose the right size chicken. Inner size of ERO-2008S/N models: 12″L x 8.5″H x 13″W.

📌 Things to consider: 

Some users have mentioned that the timer ticking in this model is unpleasant.

Black + Decker CT06335S

You can buy this model as a gift because it is easy to use, spacious enough and works stably for a long time.

📌 Things to consider: 

Compared to other models, Black + Decker CT06335S cord is shorter – 23.5 inches. Before buying this toaster oven, plan in advance where it would be placed. 


It is a great budget model.

Most likely, you will not find a similar level product from the Oster manufacturer for less than $ 300. 

You can buy this model for your elderly parents. This toaster oven does not heat up from the outside, so it is less fire hazardous, for example, compared to the Hamilton 31123D

It has buttons on the control panel, not knobs. People with wrist arthritis find this design feature very good. Also, control using a digital panel allows very precise temperature setting.

📌 Things to consider: 

When you click ‘broil’ you’re allowed to set the time but not the temp.

Useful stuff for better toasting and baking

We are confident that you will not limit yourself to just toast, but will cook everything from cookies to pizza in the toaster oven. Therefore, you should buy special convenient molds and stands for this.

To keep your toaster oven working for as long as possible, you need to use it with care (just like any other device). One of the most important rules is to keep your toaster oven clean (especially the heating elements). If your model is sold without the crumb and fat tray, we recommend you to use an oven liner.

Toaster Oven Bakeware Set

It includes a 9.5 by 6.25 inch baking pan, 9.25 by 6 inch cooling rack, 10 by 7 inch roast/cake pan and an 11.5 by 7.3 inch, 6 cup muffin pan.

Basic 4-pieces set cost about $10. 7 or 8-pieces sets are also available.


The advantages of these gloves are obvious:
1. You can really use your fingers to grip dishes and pans
2. They have long cuffs so you won’t burn your wrists anymore.

Eco Friendly Reusable Rags

10 Pack Assorted Cloths (8 x 7”). Each hand towel will last at least 8 weeks and can be washed up to 200 times.

Digital Instant Kitchen Thermometer 

1. Range of -58 ~ 572 degree Fahrenheit (-50 ~ 300 degree Celsius)
2. Gets temp readout within 3-5 seconds with high precision sensor

All models from the review 


If you are looking for a small but multifunctional device for the kitchen, then you definitely cannot do without a modern toaster oven. Many users who seek space efficiency have long opted for a toaster oven instead of a standard oven. They heat up faster, but it won’t be hot in the kitchen. The oven toaster is large enough for you to bake a cake or even grill chicken. There are several different budget and functional toaster ovens on the market in different sizes — they can hold anywhere from 4 toast to 12 inch pizza.

The choice is wide enough at the moment, so you can choose exactly the model that best suits your needs.

Black + Decker TO3250XSBWinner in categories:
Roominess & quick roasting
Toshiba AC25CEW-BSWinner in categories:
Easy to use & the fastest preheating time
Hamilton Beach 31123DWinner in category:
Perfect roasting
Mueller MT-175Winner in category:
Fastest heating
Hamilton Beach 31344Winner in category:
Smallest and lightest toaster oven
Elite Gourmet ERO-2008SWinner in category:
Easy-care system
Black + Decker CT06335SWinner in category:
Convection toaster oven
Oster TSSTTVMNDG-SHP-2Winner in category:
Safest toaster oven


🍕 What is the best budget toaster oven on the market?

Black + Decker TO3250XSB
This specially designed model is one of the most spacious budget toaster ovens (under $ 100). Its Extra Wide interior fits a 12″ pizza, 8 slices of bread, and a 9″ x13 “bake pan with handles.

🥪 What are the best inexpensive toaster ovens?

Black + Decker TO3250XSB — most spacious budget toaster oven;
Toshiba AC25CEW-BS — best “easy to use” model;
Hamilton Beach 31123D — has perfect roasting option;
Mueller MT-175 — model with the fastest heating mode;
Hamilton Beach 31344 — smallest and lightest toaster oven;
Elite Gourmet ERO-2008S — easy care system;
Black + Decker CT06335S — best budget convection toaster oven;
Oster TSSTTVMNDG-SHP-2 — safest toaster oven.

🔌 What should I look for when buying a toaster oven?

When buying a toaster oven, find items recommended by experts and users. Choose models that have been tested by tech specialist. A budget toaster oven should be roomy, have a thoughtful and functional design. Also, it must be well-built like in Black + Decker TO3250XSB model.

🥘 What is the safest toaster oven?

This is one of the few models that does not heat up from the outside, so you do not risk getting burned. Also you have the opportunity to set the temperature more accurately and as a result, the toast will most likely not burn.

💎 Which toaster is easiest to clean?

Toshiba AC25CEW-BS
According to over 730 users, this model has a well thought-out functional design. Therefore, it is very convenient to wash it, even after you have cooked chicken in it.

🍽 Which is the better Hamilton or Black + Decker toaster oven?

Both manufacturers have very successful toaster oven models. We recommend you to choose an item after analyzing your personal needs. Choose Hamilton Beach 31344 if your family consists of 1-2 people, for a large family it is better to buy 8 slices Black + Decker TO3250XSB. If you need to fire clay, then buy the Hamilton Beach 31123D, it heats up to 842 ° F.

💳 Where is better to buy a toaster oven?

We recommend purchasing goods from large retail stores that have a proven positive reputation. Also, choose stores that offer additional product and shipping insurance (for example, A-to-Z Amazon warranty).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Related Posts
?1Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!